Up, Up, and A, Uh... Hm? Where Do We Go After Up? #Supergirl
#PremiereWeek #3WeekRoundUp
Once again it is that time, ladies and gentlemen. It's been on for
three weeks (wow! That went by fast). It's time for Supergirl's
(#Supergirl) three week roundup. My initials thoughts for this show
were sparse as it premiered so late into the fall season that I
didn't see the need to think about it much. Suffice it to say that I
enjoy all comic book stuff (frankly, I enjoy anything with a good
story that can entertain me) and give most of it a chance just
because I like seeing the stuff. Fun fact: I also really enjoy TV so,
yeah. Amidst the crowded marketplace that is the comic book movie/TV
shared conglomeration multinational corporate universe, how is the
latest superheroine doing? More hot and cold than Katy Perry in that
one song that she sang. God, what was the name of that song?
Supergirl, starring Melissa Benoist as our titular character, follows
the exploits of the supposedly lesser known cousin of the man in
blue, Superman. For those who don't read the comics and didn't see
the 80s film Supergirl of which I have fond memories of seeing, let
me give you a little back story. As covered in the premiere, Kal-el's
parents weren't just idiots who were going to send their baby son off
to some alien planet alone while they died. Instead, they decided to
send his cousin Kara-el in her own pod. A girl of 13 at the time of
the planet's destruction, she was to take care of her baby cousin and
make sure he was protected from whatever foolishness might pop off on
earth.
Well, things didn't go as planned when her spacecraft got knocked off
course and ended up spending 24 years trapped inside the phantom
zone, which is neither a floating piece of thin glass like in the
original Superman movies nor penis-shaped pods that go into a
spaceship in Snyder's Man Of Steel. Here, it is somewhat of a cosmic
mist/black hole/event horizon type thing. They try not to bog the
viewer down with specifics but what we do know is that somehow after
24 years of frozen time in that zone, her pod escaped and crashed to
earth.
Already established as Superman, her cousin finds her and her pod and
brings her to the Danvers' family (do not get that confused with
Marvel in any way) where she lives out her days with an older sister,
gasp! Flash forward about 12 years and we find are humble hero being
anything but heroic. A near carbon copy of her cousin, she finds
herself wearing glasses, some of the cutest skirts and dresses I've
seen in a while (yes, straight men do notice stuff like that) and
working at a digital and print media empire founded, formed and run
by Cat Grant played by TV vet Calista Flockhart (glad to see her back
after Brothers and Sisters). Hence, Catco subs in for the Daily
Planet, and National City (hey, that used to be a Midwestern bank for
which my mother worked) is the fill-in Metropolis.
Funny, this city's Jimmy Olsen is the same Jimmy Olsen, though he's
six feet of black hunkiness and prefers to be called James (OK, that
may have gone too far, but I can admit when another man is
attractive). Played by Mehcad Brooks, James just moved from
Metropolis. Now, the pulitzer prize-winning photojournalist is
running the photo department for Catco. It is established pretty
early that not only is Superman very well established as he was
wearing the costume when he found Kara years ago (somewhere around 11
or 12, meaning he's around 36 after spending 24 years on Earth
without her; I did so many maths there), but he also has had enough
time on earth to let a few people discover his secret identity. That
probably means that Lois knows who he is by now. I guessed within the
first few minutes that he sent James there specifically to look after
his cousin Kara and maybe push her to become her own eventual hero.
What he probably didn't expect were the goo eyes she'd make at James.
That's right, if I were her friend I would give Kara a brush machete
for Christmas to clear out some of that safari grass because she has
the deepest jungle fever that I've seen allowed on prime time at 8pm
on Monday nights in a long time. Never mind the fact that her other
colleague who is a bit of a nerd (what Jimmy was to Clark Kent) has a
huge crush on her, her guy is of the tall, black, bald and handsome
variety, not to mention older. Due to what I see as one of the
biggest problems of this show which I will cover later, he doesn't
let on to knowing that she is Clark's cousin right away, so they have
to do this dance which was a total farce in my eyes.
Currently a regular 24-year-old woman waiting to make her mark on the
world, she lives alone in an apartment which is clearly too expensive
for her if National City is any bigger than a pea. Her sister, played
by the always lovely Chyler Leigh (still miss you on Grey's; still
think Not Another Teen Movie is so underrated; we won't mention Taxi
Brooklyn) has a talk with her before leaving for a flight. As luck
would have it, Kara sees the flight in danger hours later and flies
up to save it, performing her first heroic feat. Things get dicey
when people complain about how she saved the flight, having to turn
the plane on its side, scraping the wing across a bridge and landing
the plane in the river where it slowly sank after all the people were
rescued.
A clear novice, heroism felt good and contrary to her sister's
demands not to reveal herself, she does. First she tells her
love-struck coworker that she saved the plane because she, too, is a
Kryptonian. Then she goes through a quick 90s Clueless
shopping/getting ready for a party montage to find a proper superhero
costume. No, seriously, she just had everything she needed lying
around. The red boots, the golden belt, the modest but stylish
skirt--I'll give you the S and even the cape but really? Come on!
And out to save more people. As she tries being a hero again,
tracking down her first ever super-powered enemy, she gets into a
real fight with him and realizes, "holy cannoli, I don't know
how to fight." She is saved by, wait for it... wait for it...
her sister! What? I know, right?
Turns out, her sister Alex works for an organization called the
DEO--Department of Extranormal Operations. And in this organization
is where I found my most beloved character. The head of the DEO is
this deliciously over-the-top black guy that delivers his lines so
perfectly that they run the line of complete cheesy camp and
realistic seriousness. The closest thing I could think of to describe
him would be the pilots or Leslie Nelson's character in the Airplane
movies. His constant scowl and bad mood make me want to do nothing
more than flick his nose and watch him freak out about it.
Anyway, Alex has been working for the DEO for a while. Since
Superman's arrival, the governments of the world felt they needed to
keep watch for more aliens. Remember that strange ill-explained
phantom zone? Apparently Kara wasn't the only one in there. During
her escape, her spacepod somehow tugboat-ed out a larger prison
vessel which crashed on earth too. Housing not just Kryptonians but
prisoners throughout the galaxy (or universe, whichever) this dropped
a clue to the history of Krypton. It seems they served as galactic
peacekeepers/jailers. With Krypton gone villains who got locked away
by Kara's mom (a judge there) want revenge on the remaining
Kryptonians as well as to take over the world. The DEO's job is to
stop that. After a little back and forth about how she isn't ready
and is just a hindrance whereas Superman is built for this, they
support her in a fight against the big guy that was throwing her
around.
Kara saves the day by heat visioning the crap out of his ax and
standing nearby as he killed himself, talking about something that
was coming. The day saved, she escapes with few scratches and lives
to be given the moniker Supergirl by Cat Grant. There's some back and
forth about calling her a girl as opposed to a woman, and Cat
explains it away to make it sound cool. James tells her he knows her
secret and gives her a present from Clark--an indestructible cape. I
want to delve into what's wrong with this show so much, but I still
have two episodes to get through.
The second episode shows more of what the first bad guy eluded to.
Kara's gallery of rogues is led by a very familiar face. Before the
planet exploded, Kara's mom sentenced one last criminal to the
phantom zone, her own twin sister. Outside of the mind-blowing fact
that Krypton had twins just as Earth, we are to understand that she
was a general (cough General Zod cough) who wants to subjugate the
planet. Why she hasn't already done this, I don't know as she has
plenty of supervillains on her side.
Kara's first brush with kryptonite, she and her adopted earth sister
fight in a training chamber so Alex can teach her tactical sparring.
She doesn't learn much but does leave sore. Cat not only treats her
like crap but wants James to use his Supes connections to get her an
exclusive sit down with Supergirl or else he's fired. She also
suggests the heroine start small and work her way up to big stuff
after she ruined an oil tanker by ripping it open when trying to pull
it away from a fire--eco-disaster.
Over-The-Top Black guy, you make my day. |
The third show opened with the continuing interview where Kara
reveals that she is Superman's cousin. James then slips up and blurts
out that Clark Kent is superman (is there no secrecy anymore). They
find a little office space down the hall from their desks that no one
uses that they decide to make into their psuedo-base, and I was like
whaaaa? So, you're really just gonna have your superhero HQ in an
office down the hall from where you work? OK. And to top it all off
Cat made Kara treat that redheaded man like a redheaded stepchild.
"That's hair-ist!" you say? First off, don't yell at me,
because the show decided to pick on the ginger. The villain of the
week: Reactron, a human poisoned with radiation who lost his family
during a Superman rescue mission. Now, he uses a suit to fly and
fight against all superpowered beings but especially against
Superman--he's nearly killed him a few times.
When he nearly kills Kara she is saved by her cousin who swooshes in
last minute and rescues both her and this other guy who thinks she's
nothing but a menace. The hero she is, she throws a fit about not
needing his help and how James was wrong for calling him because she
could have saved the day herself. Then, during Cat's party later that
night, the guy comes back with his suit supercharged and tries again
to kill her. James runs distraction and gets the guy to chase him
while Kara is fed info on how to stop him, which she subsequently
does. Her confidence at an all time high, she goes to possibly ask
James out the next day but finds that Lois Lane's younger sister is
there to visit James. As it turns out, she also has a fever hailing
from where the lion sleeps tonight as James is implied to be her ex.
Kara sulks and chats with Superman on the computer to cheer herself
up. And as if the show couldn't get anymore cheesy, they end with her
and Alex eating while the song "Girls Just Wanna Have Fun"
plays in the background. Are you serious? Boy, where do I begin on my
critique.
What's my rating? I give this show a B-. Before you chomp my head off
superhero fans, let me explain. A few years back I was ordered to
write a book entitled The Provocateur by a group of people. Not my
proudest work, one of the things in the book is the idea that women
are constant imitators and rarely originators outside of bringing
life into this world. In other words, they will take something
already formed and created by men and make it theirs. I know, that
will piss off plenty of female readers but while the female
Ghostbusters, the planned female version of Ocean's Eleven, the
Expendabelles and a slew of other movies play into this very trend,
none of them top Supergirl's imitation.
I really like this show, but it is hella frustrating for the show to
be packaged the way it is. As much as it tries to stay away from
Superman, they mention him every single episode between every single
commercial break. We get it, Kara doesn't want to be known as the
lesser female version, but if she spent less time bringing it up,
maybe people wouldn't notice. Oddly, this leads to my biggest gripe
with the show--there wasn't enough Superman, or rather enough of his
influence.
From what the show tells us, Kal-el found his cousin out in the
middle of nowhere and dropped her with a loving family (Dean Cain
from Lois and Clark, and the original Supergirl from the 80s movie).
After that it suggests that was the last time she really saw or
talked to him, and that even though he knows she is probably one of
the only other people in the world who is similar to him, he isn't
the least bit concerned with her. Even taking into account the
crystals in his fortress of solitude, he doesn't want to know about
what his parents were really like, how kind they were as an aunt and
uncle, how much they really loved each other, or how Krypton was.
What was it like to go to school there, to grow up there, the
sunsets, the sunrises, etc.
Apparently, he doesn't care about any of that because he's too busy saving the world? Also, he knows that she'll be dealing with superpowers but it seems he never showed her the fortress, or the crystals, or taught her how to fly, or anything... ever! Listen, I know that there's some filling in of the audience that needs to be done, but to have Kara be just as clueless about her cousin as everyone else is, if not more subverts one of the main purposes of the show and it also paints Superman in an even worse light than Man of Steel did. Superman is kind of a dick to not share or care anything about his little cousin. I understand family riffs and all of that, but there shouldn't have been any of that. Superman is acting more like Batman every day.
This is your family! Don't contact me ever for anything. Love, Superman. |
Apparently, he doesn't care about any of that because he's too busy saving the world? Also, he knows that she'll be dealing with superpowers but it seems he never showed her the fortress, or the crystals, or taught her how to fly, or anything... ever! Listen, I know that there's some filling in of the audience that needs to be done, but to have Kara be just as clueless about her cousin as everyone else is, if not more subverts one of the main purposes of the show and it also paints Superman in an even worse light than Man of Steel did. Superman is kind of a dick to not share or care anything about his little cousin. I understand family riffs and all of that, but there shouldn't have been any of that. Superman is acting more like Batman every day.
As I mentioned up top, one of the main purposes of the show was to be
a pillar of feminism and femininity which I can understand. But I
feel in more ways than one that the show misfires drastically on this
thrust. First off, they called out Millennials (as is the cool thing
to do now) as being the whiny bunch that constantly needs help. Not
going to say that is or isn't true about some of the Millennials I've
known, but I will say that it doesn't look good to possibly offend
the very viewership you covet. Then, Supergirl plays directly into
this.
Not only does the show play into the stereotype that women
don't know what they want (help or no help), but that they do need
help. She has the entire DEO to help her defeat villains. Superman
had, what, Jimmy with a camera and Lois who, let's be honest, was
more of a hindrance than a help? She has a set-out model for what to
do and how to be and she still complains because she feels it's
unfair to compare her to Supes because he's a man? Because none of
her criticism could be genuine like what Supes got as a hero, it all
comes from a sexist slant? Ugh! Essentially the entire show is not
Supergirl, not a story of its own making that could have taken these
strange and wonderful turns, exploring how it is to adjust to a
culture after living in another one for so long or figuring out how
to be a better superhero than those that came before you. No, this is
Superman in a skirt. This is why people (both men and women) complain
about stuff like the new Ghostbusters, because the only change made
is a gender swap. And with so much rich back story waiting to be
mined and a virtually new character (people didn't look fondly on
that 80s movie like I did), they could have done some really cool
stuff. Instead, we get the same, "you aren't ready. Hide your
powers. You can't do this. Oh you're a girl. I'm gonna prove that I'm
just as capable as a man," shtick we've been getting for years
from other superhero shows (minus the girl part). This was also the
complaint people had with the shared universe thing for DC because
they wonder how new superheroes will act when the old ones have been
around for years. "Well, they'll act the same way and have the
same struggles." Maybe, but not likely.
With that said, should you be watching? Yes. Look, with all of the
stuff that's on Mondays at 8pm, it is difficult to type that
definitive yes in there, but I did it because I do like the show. I
enjoy the cast. I had doubts about Melissa (really only because I
wanted a natural blonde for the role as Supergirl is supposed to be)
but she does a fine job with what they give her. And that
over-the-top black guy can give Hotels.com's Mr. Obvious a run for
his money, and is worth the price of admission alone. As far as the
female audience, though I actually find Crazy Ex-Girlfriend to be a
smarter show, I think this is more family-oriented and has less
chance at producing dead air. Don't, however, expect something
ground-breaking. Also, don't listen to those supposed Hollywood
insiders that say that this will revolutionize TV and film
superheroes because Hollywood won't be afraid to make a female
superhero anymore. Don't know where they got that BS, but Hollywood
was never afraid to make a female superhero, otherwise the original
Wonder Woman show, the 80s Supergirl and practically the first three
X-men movies wouldn't have even gotten made, let alone Catwoman.
What do you think? Am I being too hard on the show? Were you
expecting something a little different like I was, knowing that Kara
hadn't come to earth as a baby? Were you expecting for her to at
least have some family contact with Clark? Do you even watch this
show? Let me know in the comments below (hint: click the no comments
button if you see no comments).
If
you’re looking for a scare
check #AFuriousWind, #DARKER, #BrandNewHome or
#ThePowerOfTen.
For those interested in something a little more dramatic, check
out #TheWriter.
The full first season is out now NOW exclusively on Amazon. If you
like fast action crime check out #ADangerousLow.
The sequel A New Low will be out in a few months. Join us on
Goodreads to talk about books and TV, and subscribe to and follow my
blog with that Google+ button to the right.
Until next time, "she's got jungle
fever. He's got jungle fever. They both got jungle fever. They're in
love."
P.S. I think I'm paraphrasing but Stevie Wonder couldn't have said it
better. I'll try to think of something better next post.
AmazonGoodreads Author Page
Goodreads Books Similar to TV Shows
Twitter@filmbooksbball
No comments:
Post a Comment